Case ce-0160-nested-formatting-order-inconsistent · Scenario scenario-nested-formatting

Nested formatting element order is inconsistent in Safari

OS: Windows 11 Device: Desktop or Laptop Any Browser: Safari 17.0 Keyboard: US Status: draft
formatting nested order safari

Phenomenon

When applying multiple formatting operations in Safari, the nesting order of elements varies inconsistently. The same formatting may result in <b><i>text</i></b> or <i><b>text</b></i> depending on application order.

Reproduction example

  1. Select some text
  2. Apply bold, then italic
  3. Observe nesting: <b><i>text</i></b>
  4. Remove formatting and reapply in reverse order (italic, then bold)
  5. Observe nesting: <i><b>text</b></i>

Observed behavior

  • Nesting order depends on application order
  • Same visual result has different DOM structure
  • Inconsistent structure makes management difficult
  • Querying formatting state is complex

Expected behavior

  • Nesting order should be consistent
  • Or order should be predictable
  • Same formatting should have same structure
  • Structure should be normalized

Browser Comparison

  • Chrome/Edge: Nesting order more consistent
  • Firefox: Similar nesting behavior
  • Safari: Nesting order most inconsistent (this case)

Notes and possible direction for workarounds

  • Normalize formatting structure after operations
  • Use consistent nesting order (e.g., always b > i > u)
  • Merge or reorder nested elements
  • Document expected nesting order
Before
Hello World
Basic text
→
After Bold then Italic
Hello World
Bold first, italic later
vs
✅ Expected
Hello World
Expected: Consistent nesting order (always b > i)

Browser compatibility matrix

This matrix shows which browser and OS combinations have documented cases for this scenario. The current case is highlighted. Click on a cell to view other cases.

Current case
Confirmed
Draft
— No case documented

All variants (detailed table)

Complete list of all cases for this scenario with full environment details.

Case OS Device Browser Keyboard Status
ce-0112-nested-formatting-complex Windows 11 Desktop or Laptop Any Chrome 120.0 US draft
ce-0128-nested-formatting-removal Windows 11 Desktop or Laptop Any Chrome 120.0 US draft
ce-0160-nested-formatting-order-inconsistent Windows 11 Desktop or Laptop Any Safari 17.0 US draft

Playground for this case

Use the reported environment as a reference and record what happens in your environment while interacting with the editable area.

Reported environment
OS: Windows 11
Device: Desktop or Laptop Any
Browser: Safari 17.0
Keyboard: US
Your environment
Sample HTML:
Event log
Use this log together with the case description when filing or updating an issue.
0 events
Interact with the editable area to see events here.

Comments & Discussion

Have questions, suggestions, or want to share your experience? Join the discussion below.